Fire Pro Wrestling Returns (PS2): The Best Wrestling Game on the PS2

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns PS2 wrestler mid-throw in the ring with the text Think you're smarter than a wrestler?

Most wrestling games reward button mashing. Hit the buttons as fast as you can and something cool happens, right? Fire Pro Wrestling Returns punishes you for that. Mash and you lose. Miss your timing and you lose. And if you go in expecting something like SmackDown: Here Comes the Pain, you’re going to get humbled real fast.

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns on PlayStation 2 (PS2) might be one of the most misunderstood games on the system, and it’s my pick for the best wrestling game on the PS2.

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them I may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you. It helps keep the channel going.

What is Fire Pro Wrestling Returns?

▶ Watch this part (1:25)

A Fire Pro Wrestling Returns match in the SWA ring on PS2

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns was developed by Spike. It came out in Japan on September 15, 2005, and Agetec brought it to North America on November 13, 2007, at a budget price of $14.99.

The Fire Pro series goes back to 1989 on the PC Engine, and it built its reputation by doing things differently. Instead of leaning on licenses, presentation or flashy entrances (all still cool), Fire Pro focuses on what happens inside the ring, and on how wrestling actually works.

Timing beats button mashing

▶ Watch this part (2:00)

Two wrestlers locking up in Fire Pro Wrestling Returns
Every grapple starts with a lock-up, and timing decides who wins it.

Grappling in Fire Pro Returns is all about timing. When you lock up with an opponent, there’s a specific moment to press the button. Too early and nothing happens. Too late and you get countered.

Early in the match those timing windows are even tighter, so you can’t jump in and start throwing big moves. You build momentum the way real wrestlers do: light grapples first, then medium, then the heavy, real-deal stuff.

Try to play it like a traditional wrestling game and you’ll get destroyed. Mashing doesn’t just fail to help, it actively works against you.

Real match pacing

▶ Watch this part (2:40)

That timing system creates something you almost never see in wrestling games: real match pacing.

  • Early match: you’re feeling out your opponent with light holds and positioning.
  • Mid-match: momentum starts to shift, and your stronger grapples start landing.
  • Late match: finishers, high-risk moves and pin attempts.
A wrestler down on the mat late in a Fire Pro Wrestling Returns match

The game teaches you to think like a wrestler. Not just what move do I do, but when do I do it. Once that clicks, the whole game opens up.

Program your own wrestlers

▶ Watch this part (3:30)

One of the most unique features in Fire Pro is the wrestler logic system. You can program how a wrestler behaves: how aggressive they are, which moves they prefer, and how they react in different situations.

Then you can set up CPU vs. CPU matches and just watch them play out. At that point it stops feeling like a fighting game and starts feeling like a wrestling simulator.

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns match settings with the red corner set to CPU
Set both corners to CP and the game wrestles the match for you.

A creation suite with almost no ceiling

▶ Watch this part (4:27)

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns edit mode, customizing a wrestler's body and gear

The creation tools are incredibly deep. You can build custom wrestlers, move sets and appearances, plus your own referees, rings, logos, belts and entire promotions.

Because the system is so detailed, players have recreated real-world wrestlers, full rosters and entire organizations. That gives the game almost unlimited replay value.

Way more than exhibition matches

▶ Watch this part (4:53)

At first glance it looks like it’s just exhibition matches, but there’s a lot more here. You get single matches, tag team matches, battle royals, leagues, title matches and full tournament brackets, with match types ranging from cage matches all the way up to an electrified barbed wire exploding deathmatch. With a multitap, up to 8 players can get in on it.

A cage match in Fire Pro Wrestling Returns

There’s also Match Maker mode, where you book your own events and earn money to sign better talent and put on bigger matches. You end up thinking more like a promoter than a player.

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns Match Maker mode booking an event card

A roster from around the world

▶ Watch this part (5:14)

Instead of building around one licensed brand, Fire Pro takes a different approach. The game ships with 327 wrestlers (plus room for 500 of your own), and the roster is inspired by wrestlers from around the world. You’ll see clear influences from Japanese promotions like New Japan Pro-Wrestling and All Japan Pro Wrestling, plus American and Mexican styles.

None of it is officially licensed, but if you’re a wrestling fan you’ll recognize the inspiration immediately. It feels like a celebration of wrestling as a whole, not just one company.

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns wrestler select screen showing 327 wrestlers

Wrestlers don’t all play the same, either. You’ve got technical wrestlers, power wrestlers, high-flyers and submission specialists, and every matchup feels different.

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns fighting style options including Lucha, Shooting, Koppo, Boxing and MMA
Every wrestler has a fighting style, from Lucha to Shooting to MMA.

Another cool detail: the roster includes women wrestlers representing Joshi wrestling, and they’re not an afterthought. They get their own move sets, their own pacing and the same depth as everyone else, which wasn’t always handled this well back then.

Ryoko Kishita profile from the Female group in Fire Pro Wrestling Returns

My first match: humbled

▶ Watch this part (6:32)

I remember the first time I played this game. I went in expecting something like SmackDown and got destroyed. Nothing worked. My moves wouldn’t land, I kept getting countered, and honestly it got really frustrating.

Then something clicked. I started to understand the timing, the pacing and the rhythm of a match, and suddenly every move I landed felt earned.

Does it hold up?

▶ Watch this part (7:03)

Fire Pro doesn’t care about flashy presentation. No big entrances, no over-the-top production, and the 2D sprite visuals are very simple. That’s on purpose: everything is focused on what happens inside the ring.

It isn’t for everyone. It’s slower, more technical, and it takes patience. My tip: start with light grapples and don’t go for the big moves until the match has warmed up. If you’re willing to learn it, it’s one of the most unique wrestling experiences on the PS2.

Collecting Fire Pro Wrestling Returns

▶ Watch this part (7:22)

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns on the shelf in the Neon Stache PS2 collection

From a collector’s perspective, this game represents something really unique on the PS2: a completely different philosophy. No licenses, no mainstream push, just deep mechanics and a dedicated audience. To me, that’s made it a true classic.

A complete North American copy is the case, the disc and the manual. Mine is complete:

Want one for your shelf? Find Fire Pro Wrestling Returns on eBay, and look for listings that show the manual.

If you’re new to PS2 collecting, my PS2 Beginner’s Guide covers how to get set up cheap. And if you’re after more overlooked gems, check out my Eternal Poison review and my Scaler review.

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns FAQ

Who made Fire Pro Wrestling Returns? Spike developed it. It came out in Japan in 2005, and Agetec published the North American version in 2007.

When did Fire Pro Wrestling Returns come out in North America? November 13, 2007, on PS2, at a budget price of $14.99.

Is Fire Pro Wrestling Returns a button masher? No. Grapples are won on timing, and mashing actually works against you.

Does Fire Pro Wrestling Returns have real wrestlers? It’s unlicensed, but the 327-wrestler roster is clearly inspired by real wrestlers from Japan, America and Mexico, and you can edit or create your own.

Can you watch CPU vs. CPU matches? Yes. You can program each wrestler’s logic and simulate matches, which is a big reason fans call it a wrestling simulator.

Can you play Fire Pro Wrestling Returns on PS3? Yes. A digital PS2 Classic version came to the PlayStation Store in 2013. I’ll always take the disc, though.

Is Fire Pro Wrestling Returns worth playing today? If you want a technical, sim-style wrestling game and have the patience to learn the timing, yes. If you want SmackDown-style action, it might not be for you.

The verdict

▶ Watch this part (7:40)

Fire Pro Wrestling Returns isn’t trying to be flashy. It’s trying to be authentic, and that’s exactly what makes it stand out. For me, it’s the best wrestling game on the PS2.

You stay frosty.

Comments

Leave a Reply